Is Animoog already dead?

Fingolfinzzz

AU is preferable but I’m not going to ignore some of the sounds I can get from IAA. There’s too many incredible IAA synths to not use them even if it’s a hassle at times. Nave and Animoog and the Korg stuff is something I’ll always end up using a lot. I do hope these end up becoming (AU but I’ll live if they don’t

dpeace

Heh!

@TheVimFuego said:
I refuse to buy any synth that doesn’t correctly handle non-ASCII characters in the MIDI port names.

Good update.

philowerx

@brambos said:
The importance of AU is only 5% about needing multiple instances. It's 95% about the convenience and seamlessness of state saving.

Add to that 95% convienence and seemless state saving the ability to realtime record and playback UI elements like knobs, sliders, switches and x/y pads!

JudgeDredd

Why oh why is this magnificent beast AU yet?

tja

@philowerx said:
Add to that 95% convienence and seemless state saving the ability to realtime record and playback UI elements like knobs, sliders, switches and x/y pads!

Why should that not be possible with IAA Apps?

And AudioBus saves my IAA quite nicely, as well as switches between them perfectly, with big convenient user interfaces, full screen.

Also, from what I read here, I get the impression that there is not even something like an AU standard.
Each developer needs to fight his own way through the mess of lacking documentation from Apple.
And that shows, with the endless list of AU problems in different hosts.

It may well be, that IAA is still the more stable standard in this regard.
No?

wim

@tja said:
No?

Not in my experience.

For every one AUv3 problem I've had, I've had at least 50 IAA problems in hosts.

brambos

@tja said:
Also, from what I read here, I get the impression that there is not even something like an AU standard.
Each developer needs to fight his own way through the mess of lacking documentation from Apple.

Back in 2016 that was the case. Nowadays the basics are well documented (also in 3rd party tuts and frameworks) and Apple’s samplecode is pretty good.

And that shows, with the endless list of AU problems in different hosts.

That’s mostly due to insufficient testing or beginner mistakes from first-time devs in my observations.

No?

No. IAA is meh compared to the vastly superior model of AU and I’ll be happy to see it go dodo.

Jeezs

@wim said:

@tja said:
No?

Not in my experience.

For every one AUv3 problem I've had, I've had at least 50 IAA problems in hosts.

I always hesitate to I launch an IAA app as it often end with a total crash.
Almost never happen with AUv3.

gusgranite

We are wolves howling at the moon 🌙

Auuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu!

tja

@brambos said:

@tja said:
Also, from what I read here, I get the impression that there is not even something like an AU standard.
Each developer needs to fight his own way through the mess of lacking documentation from Apple.

Back in 2016 that was the case. Nowadays the basics are well documented (also in 3rd party tuts and frameworks) and Apple’s samplecode is pretty good.

And that shows, with the endless list of AU problems in different hosts.

That’s mostly due to insufficient testing or beginner mistakes from first-time devs in my observations.

No?

No. IAA is meh compared to the vastly superior model of AU and I’ll be happy to see it go dodo.

Thanks.
This will renew my opinion and expectations

setAI

auv3 is a useful tool but not having it does not make an app “dead” or even outdated 🙄

RUST( i )K

No.
IT IS ALIVE

kinkujin

@RUST( i )K said:
No.
IT IS ALIVE

Very alive (in the right paws, that is).

philowerx

@tja said:

@brambos said:

@tja said:
Also, from what I read here, I get the impression that there is not even something like an AU standard.
Each developer needs to fight his own way through the mess of lacking documentation from Apple.

Back in 2016 that was the case. Nowadays the basics are well documented (also in 3rd party tuts and frameworks) and Apple’s samplecode is pretty good.

And that shows, with the endless list of AU problems in different hosts.

That’s mostly due to insufficient testing or beginner mistakes from first-time devs in my observations.

No?

No. IAA is meh compared to the vastly superior model of AU and I’ll be happy to see it go dodo.

Thanks.
This will renew my opinion and expectations

👍

justice86

I still have the very first iPad to come out (iOS 5 something). There is only one app installed on it. You know which one it is.